As much as I might criticize Jung for acting out his personal fantasies on women, I have to admit to a certain pleasure I take in reading about his dramatic relationships with a series of mistresses, Sabrina Spielrein being the first. Unfortunately this prurient desire was not satisfied in the lease in Cronenberg's film, A Dangerous Method. About the only danger in this movie was dying from boredom. Overall it lacks that alchemical chemistry between the trio of characters, Jung, Freud and Sabrina - not withstanding Emma who failed to complete the quaternity. Having worked in a state hospital I wished I had as cooperative a patient as Sabrina. Despite her physical contortions - overacted by Keira Knightley- she reveals without much prompting the cause of her problems in the first five minutes; then goes on without much of any work to spout out some of the main tenets of what would become Jung's psychology. The characters are wooden, each reciting lines that may have worked in the play but don't play well on the big screen. I persistently felt that these rich people have too much time on their hands; way too much navel-gazing. Where I imagined Jung in real life to have really suffered a psychotic break after his break with Freud, we find the character sipping brandy as he gazes on his beloved lake Zurich from the comforts of his wife's estate. Nothing was revealed in this film and I can't imagine how anyone not familiar with Jung's life would have endured staying to the end. I didn't care about these characters. I like Cronenberg's work and am therefore that much more disappointed since I think we all yearn to see Jung finally assume the spotlight his work deserves, even if it comes by way of negative publicity. Well, I need to get back to reading the Red Book which at least excited the public's curiosity into this complex man.
You need to be a member of Depth Psychology Alliance to add comments!
Replies
Jung was human. If you ever read his personal letter to Sabina in 1908, you would realize how troubled his soul was. I'm not judging him, just understanding him. When Jung went through his breakdown and spiritual experience, it injured his soul so greatly that he needed a feminine crutch in order to maintain his logical functioning required for his work and identity. In entering the affairs, he denied embracing his own feminine which was required for him to become whole and experience the Divine he was starving for and could only get glimpses of it.
.
The film depicted Emma as a weak wife. That was not the case. She was a strong woman. I believe it was twice that she was leaving Jung and he threatened to commit suicide so she stayed.
.
Freud on the other hand was a psychologically manipulative man. Four of his closest disciples, including Jung were disowned by Freud. He set out to undermine their self esteem and his treatment of them was such that two of them committed suicide ( Viktor Tausk shot himself & Herbert Silberer hanged himself) and Carl Jung and Wilhelm Reich had severe nervous breakdowns.
Thanks for the warning Thom. I may just move this movie to the "wait until its a cheap rental" from the "got to see" category.
Thanks for this review - I was tempted to go see this film, but I guess it can be missed!! Lois Carey
I would rather suggest you read A Secret Symmetry by Aldo Carotenuto.
Done, never have a problem with buying another book to read!